NEW YORK, NEW YORK, September 23, 2004: A federal court ruled against the board of the Hindu Temple Society of North America in Flushing, concluding that the state court did have authority to restructure the temple’s governing body. Judge Raymond Dearie issued the decision late last Wednesday night, two weeks later than originally anticipated. What began as an internal dispute between worshippers at the Hindu Temple Society, one of the oldest Hindu religious organization in the country, turned into a federal case this summer, quite literally, after several bitter rounds in state and appellate courts.



The Hindu Temple Society and a dissident group within the membership have been embroiled in a power struggle over the temple’s financial, administrative and religious decisions for the last three years. In 2001, as the temple was expanding its real estate holdings to accommodate worshippers, six dissident members of the society sued the board to have more of a say in the decisions of the organization, both financial and religious. After losing the original petition, the dissidents had the ruling overturned in appeals court. In November, 2003, New York State Judge Joseph Golia appointed Long Island lawyer Anthony Piacentini to oversee a restructuring of the temple, including a democratic process for electing the board.



At that point, current temple President Dr. Uma Mysorekar took her case to the Becket Fund for Religious Liberty in Washington, D.C. and pleaded for help. “I literally begged them to take the case,” Dr. Mysorekar said. Her fear was that with an outsider mandating elections, anyone off the street would be able to declare himself a Hindu and vote on decisions regarding the future of the temple. One person could get 20 non-Hindus to sign up and make a donation of $3, and begin voting by proxy, she said. “They have no respect for the faith and no respect for the people of the faith,” she said. Not only had the temple been operating under a self-perpetuating board since its founding, she argued, but the people petitioning for changes to the board hardly ever came to temple services.



The Becket Fund, a non-profit legal organization that argues on behalf of various religious institutions, decided to take on the case, arguing that it is unconstitutional for a state court to tell a religious organization how to run its affairs. In an unprecedented move, the fund decided to sue the state court in federal court. “It’s a violation of religious freedom to have a state actor tell the temple how its internal structures should be run. It’s a violation of First Amendment rights,” said Kelly Jane Torrance, a spokesperson for the Becket Fund. “This could only happen to a small religion,” agreed Eric Rassbach, counsel for the Becket Fund. The court would never restructure a Catholic church board and set down rules for electing an archbishop, he continued.



The temple’s dissidents don’t see it this way. Krishnan Chittur, the original attorney for the petitioners in state court, said the Hindu Center has been functioning in “utmost secrecy,” without allowing anyone to see the books or have a say in operating decisions. “It is not one person’s private fiefdom,” Chittur said referring to Mysorekar’s presidency. Decisions the temple’s board and president make concerning its considerable budget must be accountable to the membership, he continued. In state court, the rulings have been complicated, including a disputed interpretation of the original by-laws that the temple was chartered under when it was given tax-exempt status.



Chittur argued that the 1970 by-laws written when the temple was first started included an elected board, but have been suppressed ever since. Many Hindu institutions democratically elect their board, he said, emphasizing that this is not a religious issue. “The Becket Fund is turning this into something it’s not.” Dr. Mysorekar disagreed with this interpretation, pointing out that the 1970 bylaws were never adopted or practiced. Back then there was no building or temple, she said. “It was just a group of people.” It was seven years before the temple was built. The 1978 by-laws, which established a self-perpetuating board, are the ones which have been actually practiced for the last 30 years, she said. The Becket Fund has filed an appeal in federal court, while the temple is still appealing the appellate court’s verdict in state court. In the meantime, the restructuring and elections will continue under the supervision of Piacentini. Rassbach emphasized that the federal ruling was “completely procedural,” and that in his 20-page decision, Judge Dearie noted twice that the state should be aware of First Amendment concerns.

LARKANA, PAKISTAN, August 28, 2004: A meeting of the Hindu leaders, hailing from eight Districts of Sukkur Region including Larkana, was held here on Friday in the Hindu Dharamshala and reviewed impact of the kidnapping of Santosh Kumar, President Hindu Punchayat District Larkana, abduction of 13-years-old Kapil Dev s/o Ramesh Kumar President Hindu Punchayat Shahdadkot, torturing of Dr. Tekchand in Nawabshah and other atrocities against the Hindu minority. Speaking on the occasion, the Hindu Leaders said that the above incidents had sent a wave of concern and insecurity among the Hindu community and they had been forced to think that such anti-Hindu activities were aiming at pushing them out from Pakistan and also to occupy their business. However, they were optimistic that the Government would solve their problems and provide security to them. They appealed to the newly elected Prime Minister Shaukat Aziz to come to their rescue, as had been elected with a wide majority from Tharparkar with Hindu votes. They said the culprits involved in the kidnapping of Santosh Kumar had been identified and now it was up to police high-ups to take action against them according to law. The meeting decided to send a delegation comprising the Presidents of Hindu Punchayats of all eight Districts of Sukkur region to Islamabad to apprise about their grievance to foreign diplomats, Pakistani and foreign Journalists and the high-ups of Government. It was also decided to convene a Hindu convention to raise voice for justice.

JACKSONVILLE, FLORIDA, September 1, 2004: (HPI note: This is a small item carried in a local newspaper giving an account of a Hindu sacred thread ceremony. These are useful reports in educating the local community about Hindu customs and traditions.) Tushar Chakravarty has a unique experience to share with his classmates at The Bolles School. Over the summer, the ninth-grader participated in an Upanayan, also known as the sacred thread ceremony, an ancient Hindu tradition for boys between ages 9-14 among the Brahmin caste. During the ceremony, officiated by Hindu Priest Kanai Mukherjee, Tushar underwent a physical transformation. The Deercreek resident was anointed with turmeric and shivered as he was showered with ocean water gathered before dawn. “I can feel the wind,” he exclaimed as his hair was shaved off. Clothed as a Hindu monk, he did not flinch as his ears were pierced. This physical transformation symbolized his commitment and dedication to the ideals of the ritual, which, according to a handout at the initiation, provides “a sense of duty, honesty, self-respect and . . . the self-control required of men for good and strong character.” “I’m pretty proud that we can keep up with the tradition,” said Tushar’s father, Amit Chakravarty, who also underwent the ceremony in his youth. “It will give him a better insight into himself and how he can apply his skills. This will be a guide for him. A guide to be a better human being.” As the ceremony proceeded, Tushar promised through Sanskrit mantras to adhere to the spiritual guidelines of the event. For one year, he will recite a special prayer three times a day and follow a strict vegetarian diet. He also must not speak during meals. “I’m excited that we’re carrying on the tradition; I don’t want it to die out,” Tushar said. “Hopefully, we will carry it to my children and their children.”

GWALIOR, INDIA, September 19, 2004: A unique world record was created when around 15,000 children from 180 schools gathered in Gwalior and performed surya namaskar, “sun salutation,” the famous hatha yoga sequence of postures or asanas. The children performed all the 12 asanas of the surya namaskar taking the salutation count to an astronomical 180,000. The event was organized by Vivekananda Centre and presided over by the Madhya Pradesh Chief Minister Babulal Gaur. “The most important motive behind this Sun salutation ceremony is that there should be all-round development of personality of children and a feeling of service towards country. When they do it together it creates a sense of togetherness. And the Guinness Book of World Records officials were informed so that yoga can be advertised worldwide,” said Mukul Kanitkar, the organizer, said. “We have vowed that when we grow up we will serve our country and will stand in the face of any threat to India,” Mridul Gupta, a seven-year- old boy, said. Surya namaskar is an appreciated exercise among people of all ages and categories. It is also considered to be one of the best ways to burn the calories and reduce weight. It is often recommended for obesity.