Results of Kavadi
I am enclosing a quote which appeared in an article on the financial page of the prestigious magazine The New Yorker, on July 25, 2016 (page 19):
“Dimitris Xygalatas, an anthropologist at the University of Connecticut, who studied the effects of [extreme] rituals, ran a fascinating experiment with people who were undergoing kavadi—a Hindu ritual that commonly involves piercing the skin with sharp objects and then making a long procession while carrying heavy objects. Xygalatas found that people who did kavadi, and even people who just joined in the procession, donated more to charity than people in a control group. And those who gave the most painful descriptions of the experience donated the most.”
What I think Dr Xygalatas is attempting to show is that those who enter what he regards as “extreme” spiritual practices also develop a deeper sense of compassion and an ethic of responding to the needs of others.
CARL VADIVELLA BELLE
The article “Six Streams of Hindu Philosophy,” Jan/Feb/Mar, 2017, explains the six systems beautifully. It would help the readers if the Sanskrit words are printed in Sanskrit also. Those words written in English are difficult to read.
LIBERTYVILLE, ILLINOIS, US
I find your website to be the ultimate unbiased true source of answers for all questions any one could have about Hinduism. The very nature of explanation and choice of words is simply outstanding. There were a lot of questions in my mind about life, karma, God, idol worship, Gods being married, etc, almost all of them have been answered. I thank you from the deepest corner of my heart for your effort in enlightening people like me.
Can you please add more content on places like Kashi, Rameshwaram, Tiruchendur and explain what they are special for. Why some temples are powerful and some not. If God is everywhere, why do we pilgrimage?
BANGALORE, KARNATAKA, INDIA
I was most disappointed by the fact that you left out four of the most ancient schools of philosophy from the Indian subcontinent: Charvaka, Ajivika, Jain and Buddhist. Please consider presenting them in your next issue so that we do not get a one-sided view and neglect the vast richness of our heritage.
SALIL C. TIWARI
JACKSON, MISSOURI, US
Thank you for your note. As you may know, the Shad Darshanas all accept the Vedas as authoritative and are thus called Astika traditions. In conceiving the Insight, we did consider adding one spread to introduce the Nastika traditions, those you have mentioned, which do not accept the Vedas. The author felt that devoting just two pages to these important Indian philosophical traditions would not do them justice. Thus, we decided to focus only on the six classical Hindu streams and not delve into Buddhism, Jainism and the Charvaka and Ajivika schools. Perhaps we will present them in a future issue.
Hindu of the Year
I read with interest your article on Sri Morari Bapu as Hindu of the Year, Jan/Feb/Mar, 2017. There is no doubt about his immense contribution to propagate the teachings through the Ramayana. I do believe though that in the 21st century we also need a teacher who connects with the Hindu youth via logical and practical debates, which the youth may better relate to than the recitation and teaching through a drama like the Ramayana. Therefore my own nominee for the next Hindu of the Year would be Sri Jay Lakhani, of the Hinduacademy (hinduacademy.org) in London, UK. He is a teacher who promotes the teachings of Hinduism through schools, colleges and universities.
SAN RAMON, CA, US
Numbering the Tattvas
I read with interest your article, “Understanding the Layers of Existence” (HINDUISM TODAY; Jan/Feb/Mar, 2017). However, the 36 tattvas of the soul that the author mentions have not been enumerated.
ALBANY, CALIFORNIA, US
Articulating our Religion
I recently moderated a roundtable where members of the Muslim faith explained their religion to members of a mix of other faiths. There were twelve tables with a dinner dialog format with two Muslims explaining their religion to the others at the table. The take-home from this experience was how consistent and simple the Muslim narrative was from the different tables.
I have been convinced for some time, and further reinforced by this experience, that we would be hard pressed to find two Hindus who can articulate their religious core beliefs in a manner that is cohesive, concise, consistent and simple to understand. It is so essential that we have a narrative that the non-Hindu community can relate to and not conveniently paint Hindu religion as paganistic.
Padma Kuppa’s article seems to share my view and I am sure others do. It seems the time has come for us to develop a simple, consistent, universal narrative of the big ideas of Hinduism that we can all use as the basis to explain our religion to others.
WOODLANDS, TX, US
Sharing your Work
The London’s Hindu Temple article in the Oct/Nov/Dec, 2015, issue is a very interesting read with beautiful photography. I like the tube map very much and have shared it with colleagues in the Tamils in Europe Research Network at bit.ly/TamilNetwork.
While researching astrology on Wikipedia, I stumbled across Hindu astrology. The writing is very biased and gives me a feeling that most Wikipedia authors are Indologists or Abrahamic subject matter experts who have a negative view of Vedas and ancient Bharath scriptures and traditions. This site lacks verification from a Veda expert who was born and brought up in Bharathiya traditions.
Is there an alternative site which is authored by Vedanta scholars and Sanskrit experts that can counter such sites to which people can go to for all matters Sanatana Dharma and can gradually become bigger and well known than Wikipedia and can challenge its biased views with real extracts from Vedas?
We recommend you take a look at hindupedia.com/en/Jyotish
Left or Right Hand?
I am a left-handed Hindu. I was brought up in loving family and since they are observant Hindus, they tried to get me to learn to be right-handed; other than for religious rites when I use my right hand (if I remember to, otherwise the pandya/pujari corrects me), I use my left hand for most activities.
I was ridiculed by a fellow Hindu—a brahmin (by name, if not karmas), no less—for standing up to his mockery of left-handed people. His reference was to purity and to strict rules of leading a dharmic life. While I accept that as partly valid, my reference is to teachings of bhakti yoga sages and seers over the recent centuries, who reference passages in the Bhagavad Gita and elsewhere, and who have claimed that any prayer, any offering, made to God in true love and humility, is fully accepted by the Lord. To me, that makes innate sense, for unlike the Abrahamic nature of God, Hinduism as I practice it does not teach about a vengeful God, or a petty God.
How do modern Hindus learn to accept each other, left-handed or right-handed, of various varna/jati (caste)? How would the learned acharyas, monks of HINDUISM TODAY/Himalayan Academy address this issue?
PHILADELPHIA, PENNSYLVANIA, US
The origin of this preference comes from using the left hand for personal hygiene. We are not aware, and our readers might be able to help, of any discussion of the issue in Hindu writings. Such cultural habits resist change. We know many left-handers who have learned to eat and pass things with the right hand.
Letters with writer’s name, address and daytime phone number should be sent to:
Letters, Hinduism Today
107 Kaholalele Road
Kapaa, Hawaii, 96746-9304 USA
or faxed to: (808) 822-4351
or visit: www.hinduismtoday.com/letters
Letters may be edited for space and clarity and may appear in electronic versions of HINDUISM TODAY.