Letters to the Editor 1-2025

Venerating Ram via the Gita

For hundreds of years, devotees have been studying and chanting the Bhagavad Gita in homes and temples, schools and colleges across India. The Gita helps individuals to overcome life’s challenges by making the mind strong and positive. This ancient text is read and reflected on by devotees, students, scholars, philosophers, psychologists, political leaders and educators across the world.

Sugunendra Tirtha from Puttige Matha has initiated “Koti Gita Lekhana Yajna” for the welfare of humanity with the goal of having at least one crore people write the Gita’s 700 verses in any language in a blank book provided by Sri Matha and offering it to Sri Krishna at Udupi. 

Every day, I feel so peaceful while writing the Gita for 15 minutes. My husband and my 8-year-old son also feel blessed to be able to write the Gita. Interested devotees can visit: sriputhige.org. 

Sapna Kumaraswamy 
bengaluru, india

Kudos

It is always a pleasure to read Hinduism Today.  I just received the October-December 2024 issue and have read your Publisher’s Desk editorial regarding the inner and the outer life, with which I entirely agree.  As usual, this issue is packed with interesting articles and pictures.

Dr. Karan Singh 
drkaransinghjnmf@gmail.com

Jai Shri Shankaracharya

I thoroughly enjoyed reading “Adi Shankara, India’s Great Spiritual General” written by Swami Advayananda and Sudarshan Ramabadran (Jul/Aug/Sep 2024). Shankaracharya’s Advaita Vedanta is considered superior to other philosophies in academic circles for its logical rigor, comprehensive commentary on sacred texts, unification of diverse philosophical strands, and profound spiritual depth. His systematic approach, dialectical skills and ability to synthesize various philosophical traditions into a coherent non-dualistic framework have cemented his legacy as a preeminent philosopher. The practical and experiential dimensions of his teachings further enhance the relevance and appeal of Advaita Vedanta, ensuring its enduring influence and academic recognition. 

Pradeep Srivastava
pradeepscool@hotmail.com

I read and enjoyed the article on Bhagvatpada Adi Shankara a few days ago. One point stands out: the article propagates that the  birthplace of Bhagavatpada is not Kalady. I am curious as to where this  information is sourced. It sounds new to me. I request you to kindly enlighten me, have I missed out on something?

Choodie Shivaram
cnaglobal@gmail.com

From time immemorial traditionally it has been accepted that Kalady is the birthplace of Adi Shankara Bhagavatpada. The popular Madhaviya Shankara Vijayam and many other sources enforce this idea. When such is the case where is the need to give an alternative narrative? Such narratives will only create avoidable confusion in the minds of followers of the Shankara sampradaya. It is better not to alter such deep-rooted beliefs.

Karthik Venkataraman
karthik.i.sverige@gmailcom

Regarding the authenticity of the source mentioning the birth home of Sri Adi Shankaracharya at Melpazhur Mana in Veliyanad, Ernakulam, I would like to clarify that this information is well-known among the local residents. Melpazhur Mana, the ancient Nambuthri Mana, is recognized as the ancestral maternal home of Aryamba, the mother of Sri Adi Shankaracharya. According to tradition, it was customary for a woman to give birth at her maternal home, and this is where Aryamba is believed to have delivered her divine child. It is also the site where his Vidyarambha and Upanayanam were conducted. This understanding is not new or speculative; it has long been part of local lore. Additionally, Gurudev Swami Chinmayananda himself referenced this in an archival video from the late 1980s, where he narrates the story of Adi Sankara Nilayam. He reiterated the same in his inaugural address, further solidifying the Mana’s connection to Adi Shankaracharya’s life. For further reference, you may explore the Chinmaya International Foundation (CIF) website, or consult the following publications: Unto Research and Adi Sankara Finite to Infinite. I hope the above explanation provides the necessary clarity. Ultimately, we are but humble messengers in service to the Lord.

Brni Taarini Chaitanya
brni.taarini@chinfo.org

Guardians of South Indian Saivism

Thanks, Dr. Koppedrayer, for your thorough insights into the Aadheenams, which even many in Tamil Nadu itself are unaware of (Oct/Nov/Dec 2024). Their profound long lineage from Siva Himself and the holy practices that have sustained the spiritual power even in this kaliyuga is inspirational. Saivism is a treasure of eternal dharma, thanks to Siva and all these efforts of great humans.

Suresh Krishnaswamy
sureshaiyar@rediffmailcom

Training Priests in the Diaspora

I read with interest the article “We’ll Train Our Own Priests,” describing the conviction of Malaysia’s largest temple (Feb 1989). My reaction is that finding youths for this is going to be ever challenging. If instead you ask for retired people to train in this segment, I think it will be hugely successful.

Santhi D. A. Samy
premapriyax@yahoo.com

Kashmir Temples

I enjoyed reading “Kashmir’s Temples Emerge from Difficult Times Stronger than Ever” (Jul/Aug/Sep 2024). During my visit to the newly constructed Sharada Yatra Temple, I also visited other temples: Sharika Mata Mandir at Hariparbat, Ksheer Bhavani Temple at Tulla Mulla, Marthand Sun Temple and Sharika Mata Mandir at Pokribal. It was a happy time. I am proud that I participated in Ganga Arati at Nandalal Ghat of Kishanganga River at Teetwal on April 9, 2024, which was held after a gap of 75 years.

A.V. Madhava Rao
rao.avm@gmail.com

On Thomas Jefferson

Commenting on the article entitled “Analysis,” discussing the ideas of Thomas Jefferson (April 1988), I agree: “Yet the real genius of Jefferson was in his ability to translate the theory of rita dharma into effective political and civil practice through his creations of dharma-based political documents and dharma-based laws.” Jefferson appreciated John Locke, whose writing also confirms an understanding of rita: “The state of nature has a law of nature to govern it, which obliges every one; and reason . . . teaches all mankind  . . . that, being all equal and independent, no one ought to harm another in his life, health, liberty or possessions . . .” (Second Treatises of Government, 1689).

pauld108
pauld108@gmail.com

Tagore’s Spiritual Legacy

Reading about Rabindranath Tagore (Apr/May/Jun 2006), which observes: “In Sadhana he states, ‘Man becomes perfect man, he attains his fullest expression, when his soul realizes itself in the Infinite being who is Avih, whose very essence is expression,” I’m reminded of the following couplet by Adi Shankaracharya, recommended for morning recitation: 

prātaḥ smarāmi hṛdi saṁsphurad-ātmatvaṁ saccitsukhaṁ paramahaṁsagatiṁ turīyam yatsvapna jāgarasuṣuptimavaiti nityaṁ tadbrahma niṣkalamahaṁ na ca bhūtasaṅghaḥ

“At dawn I remember the Reality which is the Self, shining brilliantly in the heart, existence-

consciousness-happiness, the goal of Par­a­ma­­hansa sannyasins (sages)—the Fourth—That which knows always the states of dream, waking and deep sleep. That Brahman which is partless I am, not the cluster of elements.” Tagore’s poetry and philosophy appear to be a multi-faceted expression of the realization of one’s self as Brahman, and not bhutasanghah, a cluster of elements.

Pramod Pandey
pkspandey@gmail.com

Correction: Our October 2024 article on the grand Mahasivaratri festival in Mandi, contained an erroneous reference: “Bhootnath Vishnu Temple.” It should have read “Bhootnath Temple,” as Bootnath is dedicated to Siva, “Lord of bhutas” (ghosts or spirits).

The Editors


Preserving and Promoting Hinduism in the Modern World

Our publisher submits that help given to this magazine benefits all Hindus

Satguru at a temple event in Montreal during a two week journey in October 2024

Hinduism Today publisher Satguru Bodhinatha Veylanswami was recently asked in an email interview, “How do you see the role of media in preserving and promoting Hinduism in the modern world?” Here is his answer.

The information age, which began around the 1960s and 1970s, is now in full bloom. With the Internet and its 200 million active websites and almost a dozen major social media channels, there exists a plethora of information on all subjects, including Hinduism. Unfortunately, when it comes to Hinduism, information is often not accurate. There is an abundance of innocent misinformation as well as some deliberate disinformation. With this in mind, a primary role of Hindu media is to provide a source of authoritative and accurate information. We see our own publications as a trusted and authentic counterbalance to all the misinformation out there.

We share the stories of Hindu ashrams and leaders, stories from all over the globe that are compiled in no other place we know of. This tells the world that Hinduism, representing one-sixth of the human race, is alive and well, culturally rich, artistically adept, musically gifted and spiritually unrivaled.

Hindu leaders contribute articles that address contemporary issues, such as being spiritual but not religious (SBNR), the idea of secular humanism as an alternative to religion, the promotion of atheism in universities, the academic assertion that humanity no longer needs religion, and the relationship of yoga to its Hindu roots. Our team continues to actively create apps, YouTube videos, spiritual art, educational documentaries, children’s stories and more that amplify the global influence of the magazine.


To cope with higher expenses and lower subscription income, we ask our magazine donors to direct gifts to the current expenses fund at ­­bit.ly/help-ht. For gifts to the magazine’s two endowments—the Production Fund and the Complimentary Subscription Fund—we suggest that this support be done through one’s estate plan; see hheonline.org

Directing donations to the current expenses fund will ensure that the finances of Hinduism Today are strengthened, funds are available to generously distribute free copies, and there is ample income available to meet the higher production expenses caused by inflation. This will enable Hinduism Today to continue to dynamically fulfill its mission of uplifting Hinduism, Hindus and like-minded souls everywhere.

Donate at: bit.ly/help-HT, or contact us at +1-888-464-1008 • support@hindu.org

Leave a Comment

Your name, email and comment may be published in Hinduism Today's "Letters" page in print and online. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Scroll to Top